العلاقة بين تفاعلات العملاء في الواقع الافتراضي وإدارة علاقات العملاء: الدور الوسيط لمرونة العملاء الداخليين (دراسة ميدانية بالتطبيق على قطاع الفنادق في مصر)

المؤلفون

  • سماح الغريب * كلية التجارة - جامعة الأزهر
    samahalsayed975@gmail.com
  • فاطمة جاد الله كلية التجارة - جامعة الأزهر
  • أميرة الزهيري كلية التجارة - جامعة الأزهر

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.36394/jhss/23/1/12

الكلمات المفتاحية:

تفاعلات العملاء في الواقع الافتراضي، رشاقة العملاء الداخليين، إدارة علاقات العملاء.

الملخص

هدف البحث إلى تحديد دور مرونة العملاء الداخليين في العلاقة بين تفاعلات العملاء في الواقع الافتراضي وإدارة علاقات العملاء بالتطبيق على قطاع الفنادق في مصر، من خلال عينة قوامها (768) مستجيبًا، وكانت مقسمة كالآتي: العملاء الداخليون (384) مستجيبًا، والعملاء الخارجيون (384) مستجيبًا، وقد بلغ عدد قوائم الاستقصاء المستردة والصحيحة (627) قائمة، بنسبة استجابة (81,6%). وقد توصلت النتائج إلى قبول فرض البحث والذي ينص على أنه:» من المتوقع وجود تأثير معنوي لمرونة العملاء الداخليين- كمتغير وسيط - في العلاقة بين تفاعلات العملاء في الواقع الافتراضي وفعالية إدارة علاقات العملاء في الفنادق محل الدراسة».وفي ضوء نتائج البحث تم تقديم مجموعة توصيات مقترحة منها، تدعيم تفاعلات العاملين مع العملاء، وزيادة الاهتمام بمستوى مرونة العاملين بالفنادق، للتعرف إلى التغيرات المرتبطة باحتياجات وتوقعات العملاء بطريقة سريعة، والتي تؤدي إلى استجابة الفنادق لهذه التغيرات وفقًا لمواردها المادية والبشرية، بالإضافة إلى إعطاء المزيد من الاهتمام بإدارة علاقات العملاء، لتطوير علاقات مستدامة مع عملاء الفنادق.

المراجع

أولًا- المراجع العربية:

إنجي‭ ‬محمد‭ ‬أبوسريع‭ ‬خليل‭. (‬2022‭). ‬استخدام‭ ‬نموذج‭ ‬بناء‭ ‬العلاقات‭ ‬الحوارية‭ ‬عبر‭ ‬الإنترنت‭ ‬على‭ ‬المنصات‭ ‬الرقمية‭ ‬للجامعات‭ ‬الحكومية‭: ‬دراسة‭ ‬تحليلية‭ ‬مقارنة‭. ‬University of Sharjah Journal for Humanities‭ & ‬Social‭ ‬Sciences‭, ‬19‭(‬3‭).‬‏‭:‬‭ ‬182‭-‬‭ .‬146

https‭://‬doi.org/10.36394‭/‬jhss/19/3/6

الجهاز‭ ‬المركزي‭ ‬للتعبئة‭ ‬العامة‭ ‬والإحصاء،‮»‬‭ ‬الكتاب‭ ‬الإحصائي‭ ‬السنوي،‭ ‬إصدار‭ ‬يونيو‭ (‬2019‭).‬

شكيب،‭ ‬بشماني‭ (‬2014‭). ‬دراسة‭ ‬تحليلية‭ ‬مقارنة‭ ‬للصيغ‭ ‬المستخدمة‭ ‬في‭ ‬حساب‭ ‬حجم‭ ‬العينة‭ ‬العشوائية،‭ ‬مجلة‭ ‬جامعة‭ ‬تشرين‭ ‬للبحوث‭ ‬والدراسات‭ ‬العلمية‭ - ‬سلسلة‭ ‬العلوم‭ ‬الاقتصادية‭ ‬والقانونية،‭ ‬36‭(‬5‭)‬،‭ ‬1-90‭ ‬‭.‬‭ ‬

ثانيًا- المراجع الاجنبية:

Alam‭, ‬M‭. ‬M‭. ‬D‭., ‬Al Karim‭, ‬R‭., & ‬Habiba‭, ‬W‭. (‬2021‭). ‬The Relationship between CRM and Customer Loyalty‭: ‬the Moderating Role‭ ‬of Customer‭ ‬Trust‭.‬‭ ‬International Journal of Bank Marketing‭.‬‏‭ ‬39‭ (‬7‭).‬1-25‭. ‬https‭://‬doi‭. ‬10.1108‭/‬IJBM-12-2020-0607‭.‬

AlQershi‭, ‬N‭. ‬A‭., ‬Mokhtar‭, ‬S‭. ‬S‭. ‬M‭., & ‬Abas‭, ‬Z‭. ‬B‭. (‬2020‭). ‬CRM‭ ‬Dimensions and Performance of SMEs in Yemen‭: ‬the Moderating Role‭ ‬of Human Capital‭. ‬Journal of Intellectual Capital‭. ‬23‭ ‬‭)‬3‭(‬‭: ‬516-537‭.‬‭ ‬https‭://‬doi‭. ‬10.1108‭/‬JIC-05-2020-0175‭.‬

‏Andreassen‭, ‬T.W‭., ‬Blazevic‭, ‬V‭., ‬Carl‭, ‬W‭., ‬Donthu‭, ‬N‭., ‬Garnefeld‭, ‬I‭., ‬Hammedi‭, ‬W‭.,‬Keiningham‭, ‬T‭., ‬Rust‭, ‬R.T‭., (‬2013‭). ‬Beyond Traditional Word-of‭-‬Mouth‭; ‬An Expanded Model of Customer-Driven Influence‭. ‬Journal of‭ ‬Service Management‭. ‬24‭)‬3‭(‬‭:‬294-313‭ ‬https‭://‬doi.org/10.1108/09564231311327003‭.‬

Arora‭, ‬L‭., ‬Singh‭, ‬P‭., ‬Bhatt‭, ‬V‭., & ‬Sharma‭, ‬B‭. (‬2021‭). ‬Understanding and‭ ‬Managing Customer Engagement through Social Customer Relationship Management‭. ‬Journal of‭ ‬Decision Systems‭.‬1-21‭. ‬https‭://‬doi.org/10.1080/12460125.2021.1881272‭.‬

Atapattu‭, ‬M‭. ‬R‭. (‬2015‭). ‬Customer Agility‭, ‬Smart Shopping Apps and their Implications‭: ‬Customer‭ ‬Relationship Management Systems in the Digital Age‭ ‬‭(‬Doctoral dissertation‭, ‬Queensland University of Technology‭).‬1-243‭.‬

Bachmann‭, ‬D‭., ‬Weichert‭, ‬F‭., & ‬Rinkenauer‭, ‬G‭. (‬2018‭). ‬Review of Three-Dimensional Human-Computer Interaction with‭ ‬Focus on the Leap Motion Controller‭. ‬Sensors‭. ‬18‭)‬7‭(‬‭:‬1-39‭.‬‏‭ ‬https‭://‬doi.org/10.3390‭/‬s18072194‭.‬

Beshir‭, ‬N‭. (‬2024‭). ‬The‭ ‬Role of Electronic Customer Relationship Management in Enhancing E-Customer‭ ‬Loyalty through the Mediating Effect of E-Customer Trust‭: ‬A‭ ‬Field Study on the Egyptian Fast-Food Industry‭. ‬Journal of‭ ‬Alexandria University for Administrative Sciences‭, ‬61‭(‬2‭)‬‭:‬251-290‭. ‬https‭://‬doi.org/10.21608‭/‬acj.2024.348629

Bhat‭, ‬S‭. ‬A‭., & ‬Darzi‭, ‬M‭. ‬A‭. (‬2018‭). ‬Service‭, ‬People and Customer Orientation‭: ‬A Capability View to CRM and Sustainable Competitive Advantage‭. ‬Vision‭. ‬22‭ ‬‭)‬2‭(‬‭:‬163-173‭.‬‏‭ ‬https‭://‬doi.10.1177/0972262918766132‭.‬

Calder‭, ‬B‭. ‬J‭. (‬2022‭).‬Customer Interaction Strategy‭, ‬Brand Purpose and Brand Communities‭. ‬Journal of Service Management‭. ‬33‭ ‬‭)‬4/5‭(‬‭:‬747-757‭. ‬https‭://‬doi‭.‬10.1108‭/‬JOSM-11-2021-0410‭.‬

Chen‭, ‬J‭., & ‬Qiao‭, ‬J‭. (‬2020‭). ‬Research on‭ ‬the Influence of User Interaction of Tourism Virtual Community on‭ ‬Purchase Intention‭. ‬In International Conference on Management Science and Engineering‭ ‬Management‭ (‬119-134‭). ‬Springer‭, ‬Cham‭. ‬https‭://‬doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-21255-1‭_‬10

Evangelist-Roach‭, ‬M‭. ‬H‭. (‬2020‭). ‬Workforce‭ ‬Agility Strategies for Improving the Success Rate of Change Initiatives‭.‬‏‭ ‬Walden University‭, ‬Dissertations and Doctoral Studies‭, ‬College of Management‭ ‬and Technology‭:‬1-202‭. ‬https‭://‬scholarworks.waldenu.edu/dissertations‭.‬

Gautam.R‭, ‬Singh.P‭,.(‬2015‭). ‬Human Machine Interaction‭. ‬International Journal of Science‭, ‬Technology‭ & ‬Management‭,‬‭.‬04‭ )‬01‭(‬‭:‬188-193‭. ‬https‭://‬‏‭ ‬www.ijstm‭.‬com‭.‬

‏Gjylbegaj,V‭,& ‬Jararaa,O‭.(‬2018‭). ‬The Effects of Social‭ ‬Media on Youth’s Interpersonal Communication in UAE‭. ‬IJASOS-International‭ ‬E‭-‬Journal of Advances in Social Sciences‭, ‬IV‭)‬10‭(‬‭:‬23-29‭. ‬http‭://‬ijasos.ocerintjournals.org‭. ‬https‭://‬doi.org/10.18769‭/‬ijasos.415493

Guo‭, ‬F‭. (‬2021‭). ‬Research on‭ ‬Customer Relationship Management in E-commerce Environment‭. ‬In IOP Conference‭ ‬Series‭: ‬Earth and Environmental Science‭ , ‬693‭)‬‭ ‬1‭(‬‭: ‬012072‭. ‬IOP‭ ‬Publishing‭.‬‏‭ ‬https‭://‬‏‭ ‬doi:10.1088/1755-1315/693/1/012072‭.‬

Hamidi‭, ‬H‭., & ‬Safareeyeh‭, ‬M‭. (‬2019‭). ‬A Model to Analyze the Effect of Mobile Banking‭ ‬Adoption on Customer Interaction and Satisfaction‭: ‬A Case Study of‭ ‬M-Banking in Iran‭. ‬Telematics and Informatics‭,‬‭ ‬38‭,:‬166-181‭.‬‏‭ ‬https‭://‬‏‭ ‬doi:10.1016‭/‬j.tele.2018.09.008‭.‬

Hossain‭, ‬M‭. ‬S‭., ‬Rahman‭, ‬M‭. ‬F‭., & ‬Zhou‭, ‬X‭. (‬2021‭, ‬June‭). ‬Impact of Customers’‭ ‬Interpersonal Interactions in Social Commerce on Customer Relationship Management Performance‭. ‬Journal of Contemporary Marketing Science‭, ‬4‭(‬1‭), ‬161-181‭.‬‏‭ ‬https‭://‬doi‭: ‬10.1108‭/‬JCMARS-12-2020-0050‭.‬

Hossain‭, ‬M‭., ‬Kim‭, ‬M‭., & ‬Jahan‭, ‬N‭. (‬2019‭). ‬Can‭ ‬“Liking”‭ ‬Behavior Lead to Usage Intention on Facebook‭? ‬Uses and Gratification Theory Perspective‭. ‬Sustainability‭, ‬11‭)‬4‭(‬‭:‬1-13‭.‬‏‭ ‬https‭://‬‏‭ ‬doi:10.3390‭/‬su11041166

Huang‭, ‬P‭. ‬Y‭., ‬Niu‭, ‬B‭., & ‬Pan‭, ‬S‭. ‬L‭. (‬2021‭). ‬Platform-Based Customer Agility‭: ‬An‭ ‬Integrated Framework of Information Management Structure‭, ‬Capability‭, ‬and Culture‭. ‬International‭ ‬Journal of Information Management‭, ‬59‭, ‬102346‭. ‬https‭://‬doi.org/10.1016‭/‬j.ijinfomgt.2021.102346‭.‬

Kundalakesi.M‭, ‬Swathi T‭, ‬Ashapriya B‭, ‬Sruthi‭ ‬R‭. (‬2017‭).‬A Study of Virtual Reality‭.‬International Journal of‭ ‬Trend in Research and Development‭,‬‭.‬4‭ ‬‭)‬‭ ‬3‭(‬‭, ‬ISSN‭: ‬2394-9333‭. ‬https‭://‬www.ijtrd.com‭.‬

Lindmark,E‭.(‬2015‭). ‬The Influence‭ ‬of Online Consumer Reviews on Consumer Buying Behavior I Buying‭ ‬Process‭. ‬Master of Science in Business and Economics‭ (‬Civilekonom‭), ‬Luleå‭ ‬University of Technology Department of Business Administration‭, ‬Technology and Social‭ ‬Sciences‭:‬1-46‭.‬

Liu‭, ‬H‭. ‬M‭., & ‬Yang‭, ‬H‭. ‬F‭. (‬2020‭). ‬Network‭ ‬Resource Meets Organizational Agility‭. ‬Management Decision‭.‬‏‭ ‬58‭ ‬‭)‬‭ ‬1‭(‬‭: ‬58-75‭. ‬https‭://‬doi‭. ‬10.1108‭/‬MD-10-2017-1061‭.‬

Liu‭, ‬H‭., & ‬Roehl‭, ‬W‭. ‬S‭. (‬2025‭, ‬January‭). ‬Do Virtual Tours Really Enhance Customer‭ ‬Satisfaction with Physical Experiences‭? ‬A Quasi-Experimental Study on Airbnb‭. ‬Journal of Hospitality and Tourism Management‭, ‬62‭, ‬188-195‭.‬‏‭ ‬https‭://‬doi.org/10.1016‭/‬j.jhtm.2025.01.010‭.‬

Liu‭, ‬Y‭., ‬Fu‭, ‬X‭., & ‬Ren‭, ‬X‭. (‬2023‭). ‬Online or Offline‭? ‬Spillover Effect of Customer‭-‬to-Customer Interaction in a Multichannel Background‭. ‬Internet Research‭, (‬ahead‭-‬of-print‭):‬1-25‭. ‬https‭://‬doi‭. ‬10.1108‭/‬INTR-11-2021-0855‭.‬

Makki‭, ‬A‭., & ‬Bouali‭, ‬N‭. (‬2024‭). ‬Variables of Technological Development and Artificial Intelligence‭ ‬and their Impact on Modern Theories of Communication and Media‭. ‬University of Sharjah Journal for Humanities‭ & ‬Social Sciences‭, ‬21‭(‬2‭):‬622-661‭. ‬https‭://‬doi‭. ‬10.1108‭/‬INTR-11-2021-0855‭.‬

Matosas-López‭, ‬L‭. (‬2024‭). ‬The‭ ‬Importance of Customer Relationship Management Systems to Business Management and‭ ‬Marketing Strategies‭. ‬In The Impact of Digitalization on Current Marketing‭ ‬Strategies‭, ‬131-145‭. ‬Emerald Publishing Limited.https‭://‬doi:10.1108/978-1-83753-686-320241008‭.‬

Nadzim‭, ‬S‭. ‬Z‭. ‬A‭., & ‬Halim‭, ‬H‭. ‬A‭. (‬2022‭). ‬The Mediating Role of‭ ‬Employee Agility on The Relationship between Digital Competency and Employee‭ ‬Performance among Civil Servants in Malaysian Public University‭. ‬Global Business‭ & ‬Management Research‭, ‬14‭)‬3s‭(‬‭: ‬1457-‭ ‬1470‭.‬

Ngo‭, ‬V‭. ‬M‭., & ‬Vu‭, ‬H‭. ‬M‭. (‬2020‭). ‬Customer Agility and Firm Performance in the‭ ‬Tourism Industry Tourism‭: ‬An International Interdisciplinary Journal‭,‬‭ ‬‏68‭ ‬‭)‬1‭(‬‭:‬68-82‭.‬‏‭ ‬https‭://‬doi.org/10.37741‭/‬t.68.1.6‭.‬

Panda‭, ‬S‭., & ‬Rath‭, ‬S‭. ‬K‭. (‬2017‭). ‬The Effect of Human IT‭ ‬Capability on Organizational Agility‭: ‬An Empirical Analysis‭. ‬Management Research Review‭.‬‏‭ ‬40‭ ‬‭)‬7‭)‬‭ ‬800-820‭.‬‭ ‬https‭://‬doi.10.1108‭/‬MRR‭-‬07-2016-0172

Salmen‭, ‬K‭., & ‬Festing‭, ‬M‭. (‬2021‭). ‬Paving the Way for‭ ‬Progress in Employee Agility Research‭: ‬a Systematic Literature Review and‭ ‬Framework‭. ‬The International Journal of Human Resource Management‭,‬‭:‬1-54‭.‬‏‭ ‬https‭://‬www.linkedin.com/in/marion-festing-7774b755‭.‬

Shailesh‭, ‬G‭., & ‬Reddy‭, ‬D‭. ‬B‭. (‬2016‭). ‬Mediation Role of Customer Advocacy in‭ ‬Customer Loyalty and Brand Equity Relationship–An Empirical Study in‭ ‬Context to in-Store Brands‭. ‬Indian Journal of Science and‭ ‬Technology‭, ‬9‭ ‬‭)‬45‭(‬‭:‬1-8‭.‬‏‭ ‬https‭://‬doi.10.17485‭/‬ijst‭/‬2016‭/‬v9i45/104492‭,‬

Ting‭, ‬L‭., & ‬Ahn‭, ‬J‭. (‬2023‭). ‬Understanding the Roles‭ ‬of Interaction and Trust in Formation of Loyalty Toward Customer‭-‬to-Ccustomer‭ (‬C2C‭) ‬Platforms‭. ‬Asia Pacific Journal of Marketing and‭ ‬Logistics‭, ‬35‭(‬10‭)‬‭, ‬2565-2581‭.‬‏‭ ‬https‭://‬doi.10.1108‭/‬APJML-12-2022-1072

Tran‭, ‬Q‭. ‬X‭., ‬Van Dang‭, ‬M‭., & ‬Tournois‭, ‬N‭. (‬2020‭). ‬The‭ ‬Role of Servicescape and Social Interaction Toward Customer Service Experience‭ ‬in Coffee Stores‭. ‬The Case of Vietnam‭. ‬International Journal of‭ ‬Culture‭, ‬Tourism and Hospitality Research‭. ‬14‭)‬4‭(‬‭:‬619-637‭. ‬https‭://‬doi‭.‬10.1108‭/‬IJCTHR-11-2019-0194‭.‬

‏Weerasinghe‭, ‬W‭. ‬I‭. ‬A‭. ‬W‭. (‬2016‭). ‬Impact of Customer Interactions on the Nature of Customer Relationships‭ ‬with Firms Using Virtual Customer Environments‭ (‬VCEs‭) ‬of the Tourist‭ ‬Hotels in Sri Lanka‭. ‬Doctoral dissertation‭, ‬University of Sri Jayewardenepura‭, ‬Nugegoda‭.:‬1-154‭.‬‏‭ ‬https‭://‬doi:10.31357‭/‬fmscmst.2016.00266‭.‬

Wu‭, ‬Y‭., ‬Wang‭, ‬Y‭., & ‬Lou‭, ‬X‭. (‬2024‭, ‬April‭). ‬A large Display-Based‭ ‬Approach Supporting Natural User Interaction in Virtual Reality Environment‭. ‬International‭ ‬Journal of Industrial Ergonomics‭, ‬101‭, ‬103591,1-11‭. ‬https‭://‬doi.org/10.1016‭/‬j.ergon.2024.103591‭.‬

Youn‭, ‬S‭., & ‬Jin‭, ‬S‭. ‬V‭. (‬2021‭). ‬In‭ ‬AI we Trust‭?‬”‭ ‬The Effects of Parasocial Interaction and Technopian‭ ‬Versus Luddite Ideological Views on Chatbot-Based Customer Relationship Management‭ ‬in the Emerging‭ ‬“Feeling Economy‭. ‬Computers in Human Behavior‭, ‬119‭, ‬106721‭. ‬https‭://‬doi.org/10.1016‭/‬j.chb.2021.106721‭.‬

الترجمة الصوتية لمصادر ومراجع اللغة العربية: :Romanized Arabic References

ʾawwalā‭- ‬al-marāji‘u‭ ‬al‭-‬‘arabiyyatu

ʾinjiyyun‭ ‬muḥammadu‭ ‬ʾabwusrī‘in‭ ‬khalīlun‭ (‬2022‭). ‬astikhdāmu‭ ‬numwadhij‭ ‬bināʾi‭ ‬al‘alāqāti‭ ‬alḥiwāriyyati‭ ‬‘abra‭ ‬alʾintarniti‭ ‬‘alā‭ ‬almanaṣiti‭ ‬al-raqmiyyati‭ ‬lil-jāam‘it‭ ‬alḥukūmiyyati‭ ‬dirāsatun‭ ‬taḥlīliyyatun‭ ‬muqārinatun‭ ‬University‭ ‬of‭ ‬Sharjah‭ ‬Journal‭ ‬for‭ ‬Humanities‭ &‬amp‭; ‬Social‭ ‬Sciences‭, ‬19‭(‬3‭).‬‏‭: ‬182-‭ .‬146

https‭://‬doi.org/10.36394‭/‬jhss/19/3/6

aljahāʾuz‭ ‬almarkaziyyu‭ ‬lil-ta‘biʾiati‭ ‬al‘āmmati‭ ‬wa-l‭-‬ʾiḥṣāʾi‭ ‬alkitābu‭ ‬al‭-‬ʾiḥṣāʾiyyu‭ ‬al-sanawiyyu‭ ‬ʾiṣdāru‭ ‬yūnyū‭ (‬2019‭).‬

shukaybun‭ ‬bashmāniyyun‭ (‬2014‭). ‬dirāsatun‭ ‬taḥlīliyyatun‭ ‬muqārinatun‭ ‬lil‭-‬ṣiyaghi‭ ‬almustakhdamati‭ ‬fī‭ ‬ḥisābi‭ ‬ḥajmi‭ ‬al‘īnati‭ ‬al‭-‬‘‘ishwiāʾāʾiya‭ ‬mijallatu‭ ‬jāmi‘ati‭ ‬tishrīna‭ ‬lil-buḥūthi‭ ‬wa-l-dirāsāti‭ ‬al‘ilmiyyati‭ - ‬silsilatu‭ ‬al‘ulūmi‭ ‬al-aqtiṣādiyyati‭ ‬wa-l-qqianwinnayi‭ ‬36‭(‬5‭)‬،‭ ‬1‭-‬90‭ .‬

منشور

2026-03-31